Discussion about this post

User's avatar
robert iolini's avatar

Thanks, illuminating take on selfishness and altruism.

Expand full comment
Timothy's avatar

"There are many problems with such a tragic view of morality. Firstly, longtermism does not fully take progress in moral understanding into account. An assumption is made that the values of future generations will be the same as those in the present. "

This makes me think you haven't read the book, or if you have you have misunderstood it. McAskill clearly states that the current values probably aren't correct and the danger that Morality might somehow become frozen is actually one of the key themes of the book. And he warns against global dictatorships that might install one moral view and might make it hard to continue having moral progress.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts